
Employers have traditionally used probation as a trial period to evaluate new employees before finalizing their employment. Yet the hiring process itself has grown more complex, now including extensive interviews, evaluations, and background checks to determine fit for a role.
Organisations have already invested so much in determining whether someone is right for a role, so it is clear that probation is meant to establish a measure of protection against hiring mistakes for employers. For employees, it can introduce uncertainty about job security, expectations, and whether they truly belong. A standard three- or six-month period also assumes that suitability can be established within a predetermined timeframe, even though different roles have very different learning curves.
The debate over whether probation should be a pass-fail test or a structured transition for mutual evaluation is key. Gautam Srivastava, Phoenix Mills’ group chief human resources officer, argues it’s time to reconsider or even eliminate probation in its current form.
Employees face diverse learning curves across industries, roles, and complexity levels, making a standard three- or six-month probation an arbitrary suitability measure. While managing hiring risk is essential, the focus should shift from probation clearance to ensuring the right talent is hired.
Alternative Perspectives
Udbhav Ganjoo, Viatris’ global head of HR, offers a different perspective. He sees probation as a two-way validation rather than a second assessment. Modern hiring involves thorough assessments, interviews, and background checks.
In such a scenario, probation should not become another assessment exercise in which employees are simply confirmed or let go. It is better viewed as an opportunity to validate whether the judgements made during hiring hold true in a real work environment, and whether the employee is a good cultural fit for the organisation and team.
Importantly, that evaluation should work both ways. Just as employers assess performance and cultural fit, employees should have the opportunity to assess leadership, workplace culture, growth opportunities, and role expectations.
Rethinking the Approach
Aniruddha Khekale, group chief human resources officer at Varee Group, suggests renaming the probation period to an “immersion period”. This shift in mindset can help new talent understand an organisation’s cultural nuances, work practices, principles, and processes, enabling them to perform better in their new environment.
Instead of creating uncertainty, it creates a shared understanding, for both the employee and the organisation, of how to take the responsibility forward. When done well, this is one of the most useful and least-used tools in the employee lifecycle.
Organisations often devote considerable attention to hiring the right talent without giving equal importance to what happens after someone joins. Yet the initial period can significantly influence how effectively an employee integrates into the organisation.
As they work through the complexities of hiring and retention, organisations may need to consider a more detailed approach to probation. By focusing on structured transition, two-way validation, and immersion, organisations can create a more supportive and inclusive environment for new employees.